Thanks for writing this! I think it’s a great list; it’s orthogonal to some other lists, which I think also have important stuff this doesn’t include, but in this case orthogonality is super valuable because that way you’re less likely for all lists to miss something.
I deliberately tried to focus on “external” safety features because I assumed everyone else was going to follow the task-as-directed and give a list of “internal” safety features. I figured that I would just wait until I could signal-boost my preferred list of “internal” safety features, and I’m happy to do so now—I think Lauro Langosco’s list here is excellent and captures my own intuition for what I’d expect from a minimally useful AGI, and that list does so in probably a clearer / easier to read manner than what I would have written. It’s very similar to some of the other highly upvoted lists, but I prefer it because it explicitly mentions various ways to avoid weird maximization pitfalls, like that the AGI should be allowed to fail at completing a task.
Thanks for writing this! I think it’s a great list; it’s orthogonal to some other lists, which I think also have important stuff this doesn’t include, but in this case orthogonality is super valuable because that way you’re less likely for all lists to miss something.
I deliberately tried to focus on “external” safety features because I assumed everyone else was going to follow the task-as-directed and give a list of “internal” safety features. I figured that I would just wait until I could signal-boost my preferred list of “internal” safety features, and I’m happy to do so now—I think Lauro Langosco’s list here is excellent and captures my own intuition for what I’d expect from a minimally useful AGI, and that list does so in probably a clearer / easier to read manner than what I would have written. It’s very similar to some of the other highly upvoted lists, but I prefer it because it explicitly mentions various ways to avoid weird maximization pitfalls, like that the AGI should be allowed to fail at completing a task.