I don’t know if I’d consider JPAL directly EA, but they at least claim to conduct regular qualitative fieldwork before/after/during their formal interventions (source from Poor Economics, I’ve sadly forgotten the exact point but they mention it several times). Similarly, GiveDirectly regularly meets with program participants for both structured polls and unstructured focus groups if I recall correctly. Regardless, I agree with the concrete point that this is an important thing to do and EA/rationality folks are less inclined to collect unstructured qualitative feedback than its importance deserves.
Interesting, I didn’t know GiveDirectly ran unstructured focus groups, nor that JPAL does qualitative interviews at various stages of testing interventions. Adds a bit more nuance to my thoughts, thanks!
Fair points!
I don’t know if I’d consider JPAL directly EA, but they at least claim to conduct regular qualitative fieldwork before/after/during their formal interventions (source from Poor Economics, I’ve sadly forgotten the exact point but they mention it several times). Similarly, GiveDirectly regularly meets with program participants for both structured polls and unstructured focus groups if I recall correctly. Regardless, I agree with the concrete point that this is an important thing to do and EA/rationality folks are less inclined to collect unstructured qualitative feedback than its importance deserves.
Interesting, I didn’t know GiveDirectly ran unstructured focus groups, nor that JPAL does qualitative interviews at various stages of testing interventions. Adds a bit more nuance to my thoughts, thanks!
One of GiveDirectly’s blog posts on survey and focus group results, by the way.
https://www.givedirectly.org/what-its-like-to-receive-a-basic-income/