I think this answer was good, but also feel like curating it (and skipping the team-discussion that usually goes with curation) was a mistake. This answer really needed, at a minimum, a formatting cleanup, before it was ready for curation. I tried to read it, and I just… can’t. Too many fonts, too much inconsistent indentation. And I would’ve appreciated a chance to make the curation email work right (ie, make it include the actual answer), before this went out.
(Quick note about the process: I discussed this with habryka and Ruby before submitting. We had considered implementing some new features to make the curation of a comment smoother, but the ideas all seemed like they’d require some time and planning to get right.
I do think it’s good for Jim to voice his disagreement – the current sort-of-de-facto-norms around curating is that if at least a few people are excited about a post they can curate it and don’t need to get consensus from everyone, but alway speaking from their own opinions rather than speaking for the team as a whole, and it’s good for the disagreement to be visible)
I think this answer was good, but also feel like curating it (and skipping the team-discussion that usually goes with curation) was a mistake. This answer really needed, at a minimum, a formatting cleanup, before it was ready for curation. I tried to read it, and I just… can’t. Too many fonts, too much inconsistent indentation. And I would’ve appreciated a chance to make the curation email work right (ie, make it include the actual answer), before this went out.
(Quick note about the process: I discussed this with habryka and Ruby before submitting. We had considered implementing some new features to make the curation of a comment smoother, but the ideas all seemed like they’d require some time and planning to get right.
I do think it’s good for Jim to voice his disagreement – the current sort-of-de-facto-norms around curating is that if at least a few people are excited about a post they can curate it and don’t need to get consensus from everyone, but alway speaking from their own opinions rather than speaking for the team as a whole, and it’s good for the disagreement to be visible)