Thanks for this post. Whatever problems the JTB definition of knowledge may have—the most obvious one of those to LWers probably being the treatment of “knowledge” as a binary condition—the Gettier problem has always struck me as being a truly ridiculous critique, for just the reasons you put forward here.
Thanks for this post. Whatever problems the JTB definition of knowledge may have—the most obvious one of those to LWers probably being the treatment of “knowledge” as a binary condition—the Gettier problem has always struck me as being a truly ridiculous critique, for just the reasons you put forward here.