You’ve taken Yvain’s example of a bad argument to use as if it were his argument, and then called it wrong headed. You’re agreeing with Yvain. There is a difference between using an argument and quoting it.
You’ve taken Yvain’s example of a bad argument to use as if it were his argument, and then called it wrong headed. You’re agreeing with Yvain. There is a difference between using an argument and quoting it.