I’m going to reply more fully later (I’m taking a break right now), but I want to say: as an author, I always hope to receive reviews like this for my academic papers. Rare enough are reviewers who demonstrate a clear grasp of the work; rarer still are reviewers whose critiques are so well-placed that my gut reaction is excitement instead of defensiveness. I’ve received several such reviews this year, and I’ve appreciated every one.
Review of Review for 2019 Review
I’m going to reply more fully later (I’m taking a break right now), but I want to say: as an author, I always hope to receive reviews like this for my academic papers. Rare enough are reviewers who demonstrate a clear grasp of the work; rarer still are reviewers whose critiques are so well-placed that my gut reaction is excitement instead of defensiveness. I’ve received several such reviews this year, and I’ve appreciated every one.