Omega appears before you, and gives you a pencil. He tells you that, in universes in which you break this pencil in half in the next twenty seconds, the universe ends immediately. Not as a result of your breaking the pencil—it’s pure coincidence that all universes in which you break the pencil, the universe ends, and in all universes in which you don’t, it doesn’t.
Do you break the pencil in half? It’s not like you’re changing anything by doing so, after all; some set of universes will end, some set won’t, and you aren’t going to change that.
You’re just deciding which set of universes you happen to occupy. Which implies something.
I don’t break the pencil. But I already pointed out in Newcomb and in the Smoking Lesion that I don’t care if I can change anything or not. So I don’t care here either.
Trial problem:
Omega appears before you, and gives you a pencil. He tells you that, in universes in which you break this pencil in half in the next twenty seconds, the universe ends immediately. Not as a result of your breaking the pencil—it’s pure coincidence that all universes in which you break the pencil, the universe ends, and in all universes in which you don’t, it doesn’t.
Do you break the pencil in half? It’s not like you’re changing anything by doing so, after all; some set of universes will end, some set won’t, and you aren’t going to change that.
You’re just deciding which set of universes you happen to occupy. Which implies something.
I don’t break the pencil. But I already pointed out in Newcomb and in the Smoking Lesion that I don’t care if I can change anything or not. So I don’t care here either.