Let me reask a subset of the question that doesn’t use the word “lie”. When he convinced you to not mention Olivia, if you had known that he had also been trying to keep information about Olivia’s involvement in related events siloed away (from whoever), would that have raised a red flag for you like “hey, maybe something group-epistemically anti-truth-seeking is happening here”? Such that e.g. that might have tilted you to make a different decision. I ask because it seems like relevant debugging info.
I think if there were other cases of Olivia causing problems and he was asking multiple people to hide Olivia problems, that would more cause me to think he was sacrificing more group epistemology to protect Olivia’s reputation, and was overall more anti-truth-seeking, yes.
Let me reask a subset of the question that doesn’t use the word “lie”. When he convinced you to not mention Olivia, if you had known that he had also been trying to keep information about Olivia’s involvement in related events siloed away (from whoever), would that have raised a red flag for you like “hey, maybe something group-epistemically anti-truth-seeking is happening here”? Such that e.g. that might have tilted you to make a different decision. I ask because it seems like relevant debugging info.
I think if there were other cases of Olivia causing problems and he was asking multiple people to hide Olivia problems, that would more cause me to think he was sacrificing more group epistemology to protect Olivia’s reputation, and was overall more anti-truth-seeking, yes.