John Carmack is a famously honest man. To illustrate this, I’ll give you two stories. When Carmack was a kid, he desperately wanted the macs in his schools computer lab. So he and a buddy tried to steal some. They got caught because Carmack’s friend was too fat to get through the window. Carmack went to juvie. When the counselor asked him if he wouldn’t get caught, would he do it again? Carmack answered yes for this counterfactual.
Later, when working as a young developer, Carmack and his fellow employees would take the company workstations home to code games over the weekend. Their boss eventually noticed this and wondered if they were borrowing company property without permission. He quickly hit on a foolproof plan to catch them: just ask Carmack because he cannot tell a lie. Carmack said yes.
These stories aren’t really a response to your point. I just find them to be hilarious examples of the inability to lie. They’re also an existence proof of someone being unable to lie but still doing very well.
John Carmack is a famously honest man. To illustrate this, I’ll give you two stories. When Carmack was a kid, he desperately wanted the macs in his schools computer lab. So he and a buddy tried to steal some. They got caught because Carmack’s friend was too fat to get through the window. Carmack went to juvie. When the counselor asked him if he wouldn’t get caught, would he do it again? Carmack answered yes for this counterfactual.
Later, when working as a young developer, Carmack and his fellow employees would take the company workstations home to code games over the weekend. Their boss eventually noticed this and wondered if they were borrowing company property without permission. He quickly hit on a foolproof plan to catch them: just ask Carmack because he cannot tell a lie. Carmack said yes.
These stories aren’t really a response to your point. I just find them to be hilarious examples of the inability to lie. They’re also an existence proof of someone being unable to lie but still doing very well.
Many things can be done by the right people. But Idk ‘radical honesty’ adjacent ideas usually go real bad.