One factor is different incentives for decision-makers. The incentives (and the mindset) for tech companies is to move fast and break things. The incentives (and mindset) for government workers is usually vastly more conservative.
So if it is the government making decisions about when to test and deploy new systems, I think we’re probably far better off WRT caution.
That must be weighed against the government typically being very bad at technical matters. So even an attempt to be cautious could be thwarted by lack of technical understanding of risks.
Of course, the Trump administration is attempting to instill a vastly different mindset, more like tech companies. So if it’s that administration we’re talking about, we’re probably worse off on net with a combination of lack of knowledge and YOLO attitudes. Which is unfortunate—because this is likely to happen anyway.
As Habryka and others have noted, it also depends on whether it reduces race dynamics by aggregating efforts across companies, or mostly just throws funding fuel on the race fire.
One factor is different incentives for decision-makers. The incentives (and the mindset) for tech companies is to move fast and break things. The incentives (and mindset) for government workers is usually vastly more conservative.
So if it is the government making decisions about when to test and deploy new systems, I think we’re probably far better off WRT caution.
That must be weighed against the government typically being very bad at technical matters. So even an attempt to be cautious could be thwarted by lack of technical understanding of risks.
Of course, the Trump administration is attempting to instill a vastly different mindset, more like tech companies. So if it’s that administration we’re talking about, we’re probably worse off on net with a combination of lack of knowledge and YOLO attitudes. Which is unfortunate—because this is likely to happen anyway.
As Habryka and others have noted, it also depends on whether it reduces race dynamics by aggregating efforts across companies, or mostly just throws funding fuel on the race fire.