Meta: I kind of wonder about the moderation score of gwern’s comment. Karma −5, Agreement −10. So someone saw that comment at −4 and thought ‘this is still rated too high’.
FWIW, I do not think his comment was bad. A bit tongue in cheek, perhaps, but I think his comment engages with the subject matter of the post more deeply than the parent comment.
Or some subset of people voting on LW either really like Banana Taffy or really hate gwern, or both.
(sorry for thread necromancy)
Meta: I kind of wonder about the moderation score of gwern’s comment. Karma −5, Agreement −10. So someone saw that comment at −4 and thought ‘this is still rated too high’.
FWIW, I do not think his comment was bad. A bit tongue in cheek, perhaps, but I think his comment engages with the subject matter of the post more deeply than the parent comment.
Or some subset of people voting on LW either really like Banana Taffy or really hate gwern, or both.