Maybe in thought-experiment-world. But if there’s a significant chance that you’ll misidentify a con man as Omega, then this tendency makes you lose on average.
Sure—all bets are off if you aren’t absolutely sure Omega is trustworthy.
I think this is a large part of the reason why the intuitive answer we jump to is rejection. Being told we believe a being making such extraordinary claims is different to actually believing them (especially when the claims may have unpleasant implications to our beliefs about ourselves), so have a tendency to consider the problem with the implicit doubt we have for everyday interactions lurking in our minds.
Maybe in thought-experiment-world. But if there’s a significant chance that you’ll misidentify a con man as Omega, then this tendency makes you lose on average.
Sure—all bets are off if you aren’t absolutely sure Omega is trustworthy.
I think this is a large part of the reason why the intuitive answer we jump to is rejection. Being told we believe a being making such extraordinary claims is different to actually believing them (especially when the claims may have unpleasant implications to our beliefs about ourselves), so have a tendency to consider the problem with the implicit doubt we have for everyday interactions lurking in our minds.