Honestly, saying his examples (“asian” and “field work”) are worse than yours (“black” and “gay”) is very close to strawman arguing.
Well, my examples are both real and non-fringe, whereas “Asian” and “field work” are fictional and fringe, respectively. So, I think “gay” and “Black” are more central examples.
Scott also seems annoyed by “Black”, but doesn’t explain why he’s (seemingly) annoyed.
There’s a bit more here than I can readily respond to right now, but let me know if you think I’ve avoided the crux of the matter and you’d like me to address it in a future comment.
Well, my examples are both real and non-fringe, whereas “Asian” and “field work” are fictional and fringe, respectively. So, I think “gay” and “Black” are more central examples.
Scott also seems annoyed by “Black”, but doesn’t explain why he’s (seemingly) annoyed.
There’s a bit more here than I can readily respond to right now, but let me know if you think I’ve avoided the crux of the matter and you’d like me to address it in a future comment.