I agree that the new scene seems very awkward, though I’m not sure whether I would have thought so if I weren’t already familiar with the old version.
Eliezer has said that some people would have “massively bad associations” to songs in fanfics. I don’t read fan fiction in general, so I have no idea what he’s specifically referring to. But, err, given the interactions I’ve had with fandom people, I can definitely imagine them being utterly unable to see past their preconceived notions and snap judgments to logically evaluate a given scene on its own merits and subtleties.
I agree that the new scene seems very awkward, though I’m not sure whether I would have thought so if I weren’t already familiar with the old version.
Eliezer has said that some people would have “massively bad associations” to songs in fanfics. I don’t read fan fiction in general, so I have no idea what he’s specifically referring to. But, err, given the interactions I’ve had with fandom people, I can definitely imagine them being utterly unable to see past their preconceived notions and snap judgments to logically evaluate a given scene on its own merits and subtleties.
He got a LOT of complaints in the reviews about the Ghostbusters song.