Hi Christian! I’m not sure I do believe it’s rate-limited, it’s more that if it were, that would be extremely interesting. I need a biochemist.
I’m imagining an enzyme going down a fatty acid, chopping carbons off one by one, and then it gets to a double bond and can’t cut it, so another enzyme is needed.
No question that we can digest mono-unsaturated fats, people have been eating olive oil in Southern Europe since forever, and I think that wild animals contain mono-unsaturated fats too, so that double-bond-cutter must exist.
But chopping the odd bond in something you’re not eating much of is different from chopping lots of bonds in something that’s a high proportion of your diet. (PUFAs have lots of double bonds, and make up something like 30% of modern calorie intake!!)
And yes, you could excrete the excess unsaturated fats, but our bodies aren’t profligate with energy, and fats are our storage mechanism, so I’m betting they get stored.
And indeed, a lot of human body fat these days is polyunsaturated. And a lot of the fat of food animals which are fed on seed oils.
Also, I’m told that cell walls are made from triglycerides made from fats, and that those fats should be saturated, and that these days they’ve got polyunsaturated fats in them. Change the structure and properties of cell walls and I bet all hell breaks loose. Some people have told me that cell wall structure isn’t affected by PUFA intake, and some people have told me that it is, and I don’t know....
As you may remember, I was once very interested in what looks like an epidemic of mysterious type-II hormone disorders..… So two of my idees fixes seem to be colliding here.
Storing fats actually needs the body to transport the fat into a cell. A basically unlimited transport into the cell while at the same time being rate limited to do something with them seems unlikely.
Hi Christian! I’m not sure I do believe it’s rate-limited, it’s more that if it were, that would be extremely interesting. I need a biochemist.
For this kind of problem, I would recommend starting with asking either ChatGPT or asking the question on a stack exchange website.
When making a hypothesis like that, where the phenomena should be well understood by experts, the best move is to put in work to check whether they are true instead of offering them as an open hypothesis the way you did above.
Hi Christian! I’m not sure I do believe it’s rate-limited, it’s more that if it were, that would be extremely interesting. I need a biochemist.
I’m imagining an enzyme going down a fatty acid, chopping carbons off one by one, and then it gets to a double bond and can’t cut it, so another enzyme is needed.
No question that we can digest mono-unsaturated fats, people have been eating olive oil in Southern Europe since forever, and I think that wild animals contain mono-unsaturated fats too, so that double-bond-cutter must exist.
But chopping the odd bond in something you’re not eating much of is different from chopping lots of bonds in something that’s a high proportion of your diet. (PUFAs have lots of double bonds, and make up something like 30% of modern calorie intake!!)
And yes, you could excrete the excess unsaturated fats, but our bodies aren’t profligate with energy, and fats are our storage mechanism, so I’m betting they get stored.
And indeed, a lot of human body fat these days is polyunsaturated. And a lot of the fat of food animals which are fed on seed oils.
Also, I’m told that cell walls are made from triglycerides made from fats, and that those fats should be saturated, and that these days they’ve got polyunsaturated fats in them. Change the structure and properties of cell walls and I bet all hell breaks loose. Some people have told me that cell wall structure isn’t affected by PUFA intake, and some people have told me that it is, and I don’t know....
As you may remember, I was once very interested in what looks like an epidemic of mysterious type-II hormone disorders..… So two of my idees fixes seem to be colliding here.
Storing fats actually needs the body to transport the fat into a cell. A basically unlimited transport into the cell while at the same time being rate limited to do something with them seems unlikely.
For this kind of problem, I would recommend starting with asking either ChatGPT or asking the question on a stack exchange website.
When making a hypothesis like that, where the phenomena should be well understood by experts, the best move is to put in work to check whether they are true instead of offering them as an open hypothesis the way you did above.