Speculation on the Slytherin/Ravenclaw issue: Quirrell is a double impostor. He’s Voldemort possessing a Slytherin (name unknown) and pretending to be that Slytherin pretending to be a Ravenclaw named Quirinus Quirrell. Dumbledore knows about one level of the masquerade, and accepts the explanation that the Slytherin of unknown name is a private person. Quirinus Quirrell may be an entirely constructed identity, although that would make it less likely for him to have failed to remember some of the details of it under interrogation.
Voldemort himself seems like a pretty artificial persona. I think it’s better to think of both Voldemort and Quirrell as Riddle’s inventions, not directly related to one another.
But why would he go out and tell all his students that he was a Slytherin? That’s effectively admitting that he’s an impostor.
(Unless, of course, it is a purely constructed identity. In which case even the records about his time at Hogwarts would’ve had to be fabricated. In which case… Why would he pick Ravenclaw rather than Slytherin?)
I am noticeably confused. I think the simplest explanation for this mixup about Quirrel’s house is that EY forgot that he’d said he was in Slytherin earlier.
Speculation on the Slytherin/Ravenclaw issue: Quirrell is a double impostor. He’s Voldemort possessing a Slytherin (name unknown) and pretending to be that Slytherin pretending to be a Ravenclaw named Quirinus Quirrell. Dumbledore knows about one level of the masquerade, and accepts the explanation that the Slytherin of unknown name is a private person. Quirinus Quirrell may be an entirely constructed identity, although that would make it less likely for him to have failed to remember some of the details of it under interrogation.
Voldemort himself seems like a pretty artificial persona. I think it’s better to think of both Voldemort and Quirrell as Riddle’s inventions, not directly related to one another.
But why would he go out and tell all his students that he was a Slytherin? That’s effectively admitting that he’s an impostor.
(Unless, of course, it is a purely constructed identity. In which case even the records about his time at Hogwarts would’ve had to be fabricated. In which case… Why would he pick Ravenclaw rather than Slytherin?)
I am noticeably confused. I think the simplest explanation for this mixup about Quirrel’s house is that EY forgot that he’d said he was in Slytherin earlier.