With kids, some problems are a good fit for randomization. Perhaps
you’re doing a bath and both kids want to be the second one to have
their hair washed, so you propose flipping a coin. The kids understand
that they can’t both be second, and flipping for it seems fair.
Or, at least, it seems fair right up until you flip the coin and one
of them loses. Then there are suddenly all sorts of overlooked issues
and last-minute considerations (“I had to go first last time!”, “I
have longer hair!”).
The way I deal with this is by confirming buy-in before randomization.
I won’t randomize unless they agree that we should resolve this
randomly, that they will abide by the results without fussing, and
that if they do fuss it’s time-out. Even though they know this rule
with me, I still repeat it every time: it doesn’t take that long
compared to the rest of the process, and it being fresh in their minds
when we randomize works much better.
In cases where the randomization is for their benefit
(“which park should we go to?”, “who gets the first Nora cuddle?”), if
they don’t accept the terms we can fall back to neither. In other
cases, though, where I need to impose randomization, I’ll be mildly
coercive: if one of them won’t agree to these terms I say I’ll resolve
it in the other’s favor. At which point they prefer half a
chance of getting their way to no chance, decide to participate, and
confirm they won’t fuss.
Buy-in Before Randomization
Link post
With kids, some problems are a good fit for randomization. Perhaps you’re doing a bath and both kids want to be the second one to have their hair washed, so you propose flipping a coin. The kids understand that they can’t both be second, and flipping for it seems fair.
Or, at least, it seems fair right up until you flip the coin and one of them loses. Then there are suddenly all sorts of overlooked issues and last-minute considerations (“I had to go first last time!”, “I have longer hair!”).
The way I deal with this is by confirming buy-in before randomization. I won’t randomize unless they agree that we should resolve this randomly, that they will abide by the results without fussing, and that if they do fuss it’s time-out. Even though they know this rule with me, I still repeat it every time: it doesn’t take that long compared to the rest of the process, and it being fresh in their minds when we randomize works much better.
In cases where the randomization is for their benefit (“which park should we go to?”, “who gets the first Nora cuddle?”), if they don’t accept the terms we can fall back to neither. In other cases, though, where I need to impose randomization, I’ll be mildly coercive: if one of them won’t agree to these terms I say I’ll resolve it in the other’s favor. At which point they prefer half a chance of getting their way to no chance, decide to participate, and confirm they won’t fuss.