Time. The sort of massive blood loss you get from having both legs traumatically amputated high on the thighs is deadly within minutes, at the absolute most. How does Harry get her to an ER in that time? Not to mention mobilising paramedics and whatnot from their rest state to the sort of instant correct action that would be needed. Modern medicine has its limits; the wounds described for Hermione seem to me to exceed them. Really, calling Dumbledore is much more inherent—he is an experienced combatant with access to isntant transport and no need to get things from a cabinet.
Well, yeah, but still, ERs can work pretty well, wizards can teleport, witches are more resistant to damage than normal humans, and some magic potions and charms could be added to the conventional medicine. And hey, sudden dual amputation is serious, but it’s not completely out of the possible, even ten years ago, especially with tourniquets applied very soon, instant transportation, and magic bonuses.
I mean, where have you seen people die of blood loss and shock, with easy access to medical personel, and nobody trying anything?
Time. The sort of massive blood loss you get from having both legs traumatically amputated high on the thighs is deadly within minutes, at the absolute most. How does Harry get her to an ER in that time? Not to mention mobilising paramedics and whatnot from their rest state to the sort of instant correct action that would be needed. Modern medicine has its limits; the wounds described for Hermione seem to me to exceed them. Really, calling Dumbledore is much more inherent—he is an experienced combatant with access to isntant transport and no need to get things from a cabinet.
Well, yeah, but still, ERs can work pretty well, wizards can teleport, witches are more resistant to damage than normal humans, and some magic potions and charms could be added to the conventional medicine. And hey, sudden dual amputation is serious, but it’s not completely out of the possible, even ten years ago, especially with tourniquets applied very soon, instant transportation, and magic bonuses.
I mean, where have you seen people die of blood loss and shock, with easy access to medical personel, and nobody trying anything?