Right, but the problem with this counter example is that it isn’t actually possible. A counter example that could occur would be much more convincing.
Personally, if a GLUT could cure cancer, cure aging, prove mind blowing mathematical results, write a award wining romance novel, take over the world, and expand out to take over the universe… I’d be happy considering it to be extremely intelligent.
It’s infeasible within our physics, but it’s possible for (say) our world to be a simulation within a universe of vaster computing power, and to have a GLUT from that world interact with our simulation. I’d say that such a GLUT was extremely powerful, but (once I found out what it really was) I wouldn’t call it intelligent- though I’d expect whatever process produced it (e.g. coded in all of the theorem-proof and problem-solution pairs) to be a different and more intelligent sort of process.
That is, a GLUT is the optimizer equivalent of a tortoise with the world on its back- it needs to be supported on something, and it would be highly unlikely to be tortoises all the way down.
Right, but the problem with this counter example is that it isn’t actually possible. A counter example that could occur would be much more convincing.
Personally, if a GLUT could cure cancer, cure aging, prove mind blowing mathematical results, write a award wining romance novel, take over the world, and expand out to take over the universe… I’d be happy considering it to be extremely intelligent.
It’s infeasible within our physics, but it’s possible for (say) our world to be a simulation within a universe of vaster computing power, and to have a GLUT from that world interact with our simulation. I’d say that such a GLUT was extremely powerful, but (once I found out what it really was) I wouldn’t call it intelligent- though I’d expect whatever process produced it (e.g. coded in all of the theorem-proof and problem-solution pairs) to be a different and more intelligent sort of process.
That is, a GLUT is the optimizer equivalent of a tortoise with the world on its back- it needs to be supported on something, and it would be highly unlikely to be tortoises all the way down.