As with all dating, supply and demand means that these dating documents will mostly be used by women to decide which of the dozens of male suitors to accept. And as with all dating apps, the women will all try to choose the one tall rich high-status handsome dude while barely glancing at 80% of men.
In the market for casual sex and the market for longterm relationships, the skew of the market is actually the other way around and your market value can be very different, which is why some people go for an ambigous strategy to end up with higher value mates. (Which is probably not the best strategy to end up in a happy relationship)
I thought dating apps were bad, but actually writing out a full document with long lists of every possible reason someone else might want to reject you?
Given that it is one of the major decisions of your live it would make sense to try to get as much information as possible and additionally you have a smaller cost for being explicit in rationalists circles.
In the market for casual sex and the market for longterm relationships, the skew of the market is actually the other way around and your market value can be very different, which is why some people go for an ambigous strategy to end up with higher value mates. (Which is probably not the best strategy to end up in a happy relationship)
Given that it is one of the major decisions of your live it would make sense to try to get as much information as possible and additionally you have a smaller cost for being explicit in rationalists circles.